ARTICLE
16 November 2026

Structural Shift in the Regional Disparity of Digital Financial Inclusion in China and the Provincial Border Effect

Hongmin Zhang1 ,  Xiangyang Xu1
Show Less
1 School of Finance, Harbin University of Commerce, Harbin 150028, Heilongjiang, China
PBES 2026 , 9(10), 73–85; https://doi.org/10.26689/PBES.v9i10.16190
© 2026 by the Author(s). Licensee: Bio-Byword Scientific Publishing Pty Ltd, Australia. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ )
Abstract

Drawing on a balanced panel of 329 prefecture-level cities from the Peking University Digital Financial Inclusion Index over 2011–2023, this study applies the adjacent-city-pair border effect test, which, so far as our search extends, has not previously been used in research on digital financial inclusion. Aggregate disparity has narrowed markedly, with the Gini coefficient of the aggregate index falling from 0.175 to 0.046. The spatial structure, however, reversed over the same period: for usage depth, the between-province contribution rose from 56.2% to 75.9%, the Dagum transvariation component fell from 18.8% to 10.6%, and Moran’s I under same-province weights rose from 0.438 to 0.700; a randomization test shows the between-group share under the true provincial grouping is 8.3 times that under random groupings. The Phillips-Sul log t test rejects overall convergence for the aggregate index (t = −5.020) but not for the three sub-dimensions, while 24 of 26 testable provinces fail to reject within-province convergence in usage depth. Using 867 geographically adjacent city pairs and controlling for centroid distance, the within-pair baseline difference and six city-level variables covering output per capita, population, industrial structure and financial depth, cross-province pairs display a usage-depth gap 0.0091 larger than within-province pairs (P = 0.035; randomization-inference empirical P = 0.013), robust across distance bandwidths, caliper-matched samples and alternative border definitions, with an insignificant pseudo-border placebo. For coverage breadth, the sign reverses across specifications, so no robust effect is found. Access to digital finance has become broadly equalized across provinces, whereas usage intensity remains organized along provincial administrative boundaries.

Keywords
Digital financial inclusion
Border effect
Regional disparity
Dagum Gini decomposition
Convergence club
References

[1] Lü CC, He JH, 2023, Regional Differences, Distributional Dynamics and Convergence of China’s Fintech Development. Research on Financial and Economic Issues, 2023(4): 43–57.

[2] Zhang GJ, Liang ZY, Wu ZS, 2024, Evolution of Digital Financial Inclusion in China’s Urban Agglomerations and Its Effect on High-Quality Development. Geographical Research, 43(3): 621–639.

[3] Institute of Digital Finance, Peking University, 2024, The Peking University Digital Financial Inclusion Index of China (2011–2023), Institute of Digital Finance, Peking University, Beijing.

[4] Ding ZG, Tian Y, 2025, Dynamic Coordinated Development of the Digital Financial Inclusion System from the Perspective of Geographical Spillover Effects. Journal of Northeastern University (Social Science), 27(2): 26–39.

[5] Chai D, Shang JY, Yang RZ, et al., 2026, Spatial Convergence Effect and Driving Mechanism of Digital Financial Inclusion on the Urban–Rural Income Gap. Economic Geography, 46(7): 38–48.

[6] Zeng Y, Zha JJ, Yang HS, et al., 2024, Development Modes of Digital Financial Inclusion in China: An Economic and Livelihood Perspective. Economic Research Journal, 59(8): 39–56.

[7] McCallum J, 1995, National Borders Matter: Canada-U.S. Regional Trade Patterns. American Economic Review, 85(3): 615–623.

[8] Wang CL, Liu H, Zhang MT, 2016, Progress and Prospects of Research on Border Effects. Progress in Geography, 35(9): 1109–1118.

[9] Meng G, Wang KY, Wang FY, et al., 2023, Thirty Years of Research on China’s Administrative Divisions: Progress, Implications and Prospects. Progress in Geography, 42(5): 982–997.

[10] Guo H, Minier J, 2021, Borders, Geography, and Economic Activity: The Case of China. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 90: 103700.

[11] Yang B, et al., 2022, Do Border Effects Alter Regional Development: Evidence from a Quasi-natural Experiment in China. Journal of Economic Geography, 22(1): 103–127.

[12] Li X, Shi D, Zhou S, 2023, The Minimum Wage and the Locations of New Business Entries in China: Estimates Based on a Refined Border Approach. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 99: 103876.

[13] Cai GW, Chen SH, Li B, 2023, Provincial Administrative Border Effects on Trade Flows in the National Market: Evidence from Prefecture-Level VAT Invoices. Economic Research Journal, 58(3): 59–77.

[14] Guo F, Xiong YJ, Shi QL, et al., 2023, Revisiting the Digital Economy and Economic Development in Administrative Border Areas: Evidence from Satellite Night-Light Data. Journal of Management World, 39(4): 16–34.

[15] Zhang A, Sun JW, 2023, Digital Infrastructure, Border Effects and Regional Development Gaps. Urban Problems, 2023(10): 77–84.

[16] Yang WP, Xia T, 2024, The Digital Economy and Inter-Provincial Trade Growth: With a Discussion of Its Impact on the Border Effect. Journal of Shanghai University of Finance and Economics, 26(4): 64–76.

[17] Hau H, Huang YP, Lin C, et al., 2024, FinTech Credit and Entrepreneurial Growth. Journal of Finance, 79(5): 3309–3359.

[18] Higgins S, 2024, Financial Technology Adoption: Network Externalities of Cashless Payments in Mexico. American Economic Review, 114(11): 3469–3512.

[19] Guo F, Wang JY, Wang F, et al., 2020, Measuring the Development of Digital Financial Inclusion in China: Index Compilation and Spatial Characteristics. China Economic Quarterly, 19(4): 1401–1418.

[20] Dagum C, 1997, A New Approach to the Decomposition of the Gini Income Inequality Ratio. Empirical Economics, 22(4): 515–531.

[21] Anselin L, 1995, Local Indicators of Spatial Association—LISA. Geographical Analysis, 27(2): 93–115.

[22] Guo F, Kong T, Wang JY, 2017, An Analysis of the Spatial Agglomeration Effect of Internet Finance: Evidence from the Internet Finance Development Index. Studies of International Finance, 2017(8): 75–85.

[23] Phillips PCB, Sul D, 2007, Transition Modeling and Econometric Convergence Tests. Econometrica, 75(6): 1771–1855.

[24] Barro RJ, Sala-i-Martin X, 1992, Convergence. Journal of Political Economy, 100(2): 223–251.

[25] Quah DT, 1993, Empirical Cross-Section Dynamics in Economic Growth. European Economic Review, 37(2–3): 426–434.

[26] Liu ZS, Lai BB, Liu GH, 2023, Regional Competition, the Promotion of Digital Financial Inclusion and Green Economic Efficiency. Management Review, 35(1): 40–51.

[27] State Council of the People’s Republic of China, 2023, Implementation Opinions of the State Council on Promoting the High-Quality Development of Inclusive Finance, Guo Fa [2023] No. 15, Bulletin of the State Council, 2023(30).

[28] He ZG, Huang J, Zhou J, 2023, Open Banking: Credit Market Competition When Borrowers Own the Data. Journal of Financial Economics, 147(2): 449–474.

[29] China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, 2020, Interim Measures for the Administration of Internet Loans of Commercial Banks, CBIRC Order No. 9 of 2020, Beijing.

[30] General Office of the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, 2021, Notice on Further Regulating the Internet Loan Business of Commercial Banks, Yin Bao Jian Ban Fa [2021] No. 24, Beijing.

Share
Back to top